Should You Move From Manhattan to Another Borough?

Get Your Free Moving Quote

    The hustle and bustle of Manhattan—the bright lights, towering skyscrapers, and non-stop energy—might have charmed you once. But like many others, you may now be contemplating the possibility to move from Manhattan to another borough. The reasons are many: perhaps to find a more spacious living environment, to enjoy a quieter pace, or to simply cut down on living expenses. Whatever the reason, the question remains: Is this move right for you? In this post, we’ll delve deep into the contrasts and comparisons between Manhattan and the other New York City boroughs, aiming to provide you with a comprehensive understanding to make the best decision for your next move. If you, in the end, decide to move, some of the best movers in New York will be there to help you. So, don’t wait any longer and keep reading!

    Manhattan vs. other boroughs – how to make a decision?

    Manhattan, often dubbed the cultural and financial heart of New York City, is a vibrant tapestry of history, art, commerce, and global influences. Its iconic skyline, dotted with skyscrapers like the Empire State Building, and its streets pulsing with ceaseless energy make it an epicenter of ambition and dreams. For that reason, Manhattan movers always have a lot of work to do in helping people realize their Manhattan dreams. But beyond the island of Manhattan stretch four other distinct boroughs, each boasting its own unique character:

    • Brooklyn, with its dynamic arts scene and historic neighborhoods;
    • Queens, a global melting pot with rich cultural enclaves;
    • The Bronx, a blend of urban vitality and green expanses;
    • Staten Island, which offers suburban tranquility amidst its natural beauty.
    A view of a bridge in Staten Island during the night
    Staten Island can be considered a forgotten borough

    In the ensuing comparisons, we’ll dive deep into aspects such as housing costs, cultural vibes, and transportation conveniences, aiming to shed light on the multifaceted allure of each borough in relation to Manhattan.

    Manhattan vs. Brooklyn

    Manhattan, with its iconic landmarks and proximity to major businesses, has always commanded premium housing prices. The median rent for a one-bedroom apartment in neighborhoods like Tribeca or SoHo can easily exceed $3,500 per month. This contrasts sharply with Brooklyn’s traditionally more reasonable rates. For instance, in the early 2000s, one could snag a decent Brooklyn apartment for under $2,000. However, with the rise in Brooklyn’s popularity, gentrification has followed suit. Trendy areas such as Williamsburg and DUMBO have seen rents climb steeply, with median prices for one-bedrooms approaching or even surpassing $3,000. Yet, if one is contemplating the decision to move from Manhattan to another borough for budgetary reasons, they could still find solace in neighborhoods further from Downtown Brooklyn, such as Midwood or Sheepshead Bay, where rents often hover around $1,500 for similar spaces.

    Vibe and culture

    The cultural vibrancy of both Manhattan and Brooklyn cannot be understated. Manhattan, with its sprawling museums, Broadway theatres, and international events, offers a global stage. Here, a night out could mean catching a groundbreaking show on Broadway or dining at a Michelin-starred restaurant. On the other hand, Brooklyn presents a different allure. Its cultural fabric is interwoven with indie concerts in Bushwick, artisanal markets in Fort Greene, and art galleries showcasing local talents in Red Hook. The borough exudes a communal spirit, perhaps best represented by the events at Prospect Park or the annual Brooklyn Book Festival. Those who value community engagement and a touch of bohemian spirit might find Brooklyn’s cultural landscape more appealing.

    It’s worth noting that for many businesses that have their headquarters in Manhattan, their employees often find Brooklyn an attractive residential option, especially given the comparative ease of commuting. If you’re considering moving from Brooklyn to Manhattan for business, think again because commuting has never been easier.

    A stadium in the Bronx you can visit after you decide to move from Manhattan to another borough
    A move from Manhattan to another borough can have many advantages


    Manhattan’s connectivity is one of its strongest suits, with most places accessible via a short subway ride. However, when it comes to commuting between Brooklyn and Manhattan, the options are pleasantly diverse. The Brooklyn-Queens Expressway offers a direct vehicular route, while several subway lines, such as the A, C, F, and L, ensure that residents can hop between the boroughs with ease. For instance, living in prime Brooklyn neighborhoods like Brooklyn Heights or Park Slope ensures a commute under 30 minutes to most parts of Manhattan. Furthermore, when making the move between the boroughs, wherever in Manhattan you live, the transport will be easy. For example, if you are in Nolita, movers in Nolita won’t have a problem navigating the traffic when you decide to move to Brooklyn.

    Manhattan vs. Queens

    For those looking to stretch their legs without stretching their wallets, Queens can be a real haven. The borough typically provides residents with a more generous living space for their buck, especially when compared to the compact apartments of Manhattan. As the city’s landscape has evolved, areas in Queens like Long Island City, situated just across the East River from Manhattan, have experienced a surge in housing prices. With its shiny new high-rises, the neighborhood offers Manhattan-esque views without the Manhattan price tag – although it’s inching closer every year. However, if one’s primary motivation is to move from Manhattan to another borough for more affordable housing, neighborhoods like Flushing or Astoria emerge as top choices. They strike an optimal balance between cost-effectiveness and modern amenities, with median rents for a one-bedroom apartment often hovering between $1,800 to $2,400, depending on the specific area and its proximity to transportation hubs.

    A neighborhood in The Bronx
    You can enjoy each Manhattan borough

    The melting pot of Queens

    Manhattan may be the world’s business capital, but Queens takes the crown when it comes to cultural diversity. Home to New York’s two major airports, Queens has long been the landing spot for immigrants, turning it into a tapestry of global cultures. From the savory empanadas of Jackson Heights’ Latin community to the vibrant Diwali celebrations in the Indian pockets of Richmond Hill, Queens offers a world tour within its borders. Astoria, for example, is famed for its Greek community and eateries, while Flushing boasts one of the city’s largest Chinese populations. Keep in mind that this authenticity sets Queens apart when considering Manhattan or Queens.

    Convenient connections

    Connectivity is one of Queens’ strong suits. A multitude of subway lines, including the 7, E, F, and R trains, ensures that residents can effortlessly transition between Queens and Manhattan. A ride from Astoria to Midtown, for instance, can be as swift as 20 minutes. For those residing further east in Queens, the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) offers a speedy alternative. Originating from Penn Station in Manhattan, the LIRR sprawls out to various Queens neighborhoods, including Bayside, Little Neck, and Jamaica, making the commute convenient for many. For residents considering the move from Manhattan to another borough, the ease of transportation and the multiple options available can make Queens an attractive destination.

    Manhattan vs. The Bronx

    When the conversation turns to affordable housing within New York City’s boroughs, The Bronx frequently comes out on top. This borough offers a medley of housing options that can cater to a range of budgets. The leafy neighborhood of Riverdale, perched atop a hill overlooking the Hudson River, provides a suburban ambiance that contrasts with the city’s general hustle and bustle. Here, one can find more spacious apartments and homes, with rents for a one-bedroom typically ranging between $1,500 to $2,200, depending on the specific amenities and views on offer. On the other hand, South Bronx, a place historically overlooked, is in the throes of significant revitalization. New developments are cropping up, and while rents here are gradually rising, they still remain markedly lower than Manhattan’s average. For those considering a move from Manhattan to another borough, The Bronx can serve as a cost-effective sanctuary.

    Bronx’s diverse offering

    Beyond its affordability, The Bronx boasts a rich tapestry of attractions and cultural landmarks. The hum of the crowds at Yankee Stadium, especially during baseball season, is a testament to the borough’s sports fervor. Meanwhile, the Bronx Zoo, one of the largest metropolitan zoos in the world, offers a wildlife retreat in the heart of the city. Adjacent to it, the New York Botanical Garden stands as an oasis of calm, its lush landscapes and seasonal exhibitions making it a favorite among locals and tourists alike. While Manhattan is characterized by its skyscrapers and bustling streets, The Bronx provides a harmonious blend of urban vigor and refreshing green expanses. For those considering moving from Manhattan to Bronx, the shift in ambiance from the concrete jungle to a more varied terrain is something to anticipate with excitement.

    Buildings in Brooklyn
    Brooklyn is one of the most popular boroughs

    Stay connected in The Bronx

    Despite its relative distance from Manhattan’s core, The Bronx offers commendable transportation links that ensure residents aren’t left feeling isolated. Several subway lines, including the 2, 4, 5, and 6, weave through the borough, facilitating easy access to Manhattan. Many of these lines can get commuters into Midtown in under 40 minutes. For those in the northern parts of The Bronx, the Metro-North Railroad offers a swift and comfortable alternative, with stations like Fordham and Riverdale connecting to Grand Central Terminal in roughly 30 minutes. However, a vital point to consider when choosing a location within The Bronx is its proximity to these subway and train lines. Ensuring easy access to transportation can significantly enhance the living experience, especially if regular commuting is on the agenda.

    Manhattan vs. Staten Island

    Looking for space without the Manhattan price tag? Staten Island might be your answer. The borough offers a marked contrast to Manhattan’s dense urban landscape. Here, residents enjoy larger homes, often complete with yards, all at a fraction of Manhattan’s rates. A typical one-bedroom might cost between $1,200 to $1,700 monthly, though prices vary based on neighborhood and home type. Those eager to move from Manhattan to another borough will find Staten Island’s spacious offerings hard to resist.

    People standing on a bridge
    There is beaty everywhere in NYC

    Rediscovering the “Forgotten Borough”

    Staten Island, sometimes overshadowed by its larger counterparts, has its unique charm. It promises a tranquil suburban environment. Instead of towering skyscrapers, one finds parks, beaches, and historical sites. The Snug Harbor Cultural Center and Botanical Garden, for instance, offer both cultural and recreational activities. And for beach enthusiasts? South Beach and Midland Beach provide beautiful coastlines and boardwalks. Those contemplating moving from Manhattan to Staten Island should anticipate a lifestyle shift. The hustle and bustle give way to a slower, more peaceful rhythm.

    Scenic journeys and practical routes

    The Staten Island Ferry, a staple for many residents, offers picturesque Manhattan views. While it takes longer than a subway ride, the scenery compensates. Apart from the ferry, Staten Island has buses and the Staten Island Railway to aid internal commuting. However, potential residents should prioritize transportation. Proximity to the ferry or railway can transform the commuting experience. For those on the move, considering professional assistance might be prudent. Even if you decide to move your business, you can find commercial movers in Manhattan who can ensure a seamless transition, handling logistics with expertise.

    Buildings in NYC
    Make the best of your move to any of NYC’s boroughs

    Each move from Manhattan to another borough can be an extraordinary experience

    Choosing to move from Manhattan to another borough is a significant decision. Each borough presents unique offerings. While Manhattan dazzles with its urban energy, the outer boroughs provide varied atmospheres. Brooklyn offers cultural richness. Queens boasts diversity. The Bronx combines affordability with iconic landmarks. Staten Island shines with its suburban tranquility. Before making a move, consider the lifestyle shifts and practical aspects. Whether it’s housing, culture, or transportation, weigh the pros and cons. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences. But remember: New York City, in all its facets, never ceases to amaze. Whatever borough you call home, adventures await.


    Get Your Free Moving Quote